Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Final Drive Transplant _ Kudos 2 Chop!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Final Drive Transplant _ Kudos 2 Chop!

    First let me say this is absolutely the most straight forward mod I’ve ever done to my Eleven. And the results are spectacular. I am so utterly please with this modification I would recommend it highly to any Eleven owner that is not pre-occupied with ¼ mile times. If you want a top end – gas sipping XS11 this mod is the BOMB SCHNIZZLE. You won’t regret it. Besides it is so easy to do (other than a few hours of time) you could easily revert to the OEM drive if you want lower gears.

    Secondly I must pay “kudos” to Chop (xschop). I nominate Chop for coming up with the coolest mod for 2006. I’m not sure what inspired him to experiment…and I am not sure I care to know. IT WORKS! The rev reductions are not only real but are very significant. At the end of this procedure I will post my real world results. In short they are outstanding.



    I stripped all the old paint (silver) off the unit as I will paint it black to match the oem drive. Notice the XS750 has lubrication (spooge) holes in the base of the gear coupling. The 750 shaft also incorporates an oil seal that allows oil to circulate into the coupling house and lube the drive spline. The seal on the 750 shaft contains the oil in the gear coupling.







    Also notice how the spline are recessed into the gear coupling. This recession is where the shaft seal seats to retain gear oil. The Eleven does not employ this style of lube system. The Eleven has no “spooge” hole and uses instead grease. Personally I think the Eleven is a superior system. With the Eleven there is no possibility of oil seal failure and thus leaks. So I sealed the spooge holes in the 750 drive with liquid gasket and covered them with a standard ½ flat washer (the perfect size by virtue of serendipity).



    First to remove the pinion retainer nut as seen above you’ll need to have some way to hold the ring gear backup while you break the pinion retainer. I used an old XS wheel I had , then a 22mm socket on an air impact.



    Next I removed the pinion assembly. When Chop removed his he said only the gear coupling came out and he never saw the pinion gear. My didn’t break there. The whole pinion assembly came out. No big deal.



    The gear coupling is what receives the splines on the drive end of the shaft. Remember the lube holes and pinion shims. We’ll touch on these later.

    After tapping the gear coupling on the floor, you should see a retainer nut (22mm) and a washer plate…and maybe a couple bearing spacers. Don’t freak if yours doesn’t have a spacer. This was the way it was manufactured. I’m guessing slight variations in machining would require different spacers for any individual housing. Much like the pinion and ring gear shims. No two drives are identical with this regard.



    The replacement washer (1/2 flat washer) just so happens to be a perfect replacement to seal the spooge holes. I’ve only ridden mine about 30 miles with no leaks. But Chop has several hundred miles on his unit with no problems.

    Next I pumped a little liquid gasket (Right Stuff – NAPA) into the spooge holes. This sealant is very effective especially in low temperature applications (less than 450 degrees). It will seal even on an oily surface. However to be sure …clean all surfaces with carb or brake cleaner and let dry.


    Next put a thin film of sealant on the back of the washer. Replace the spacers (if applicable), then the ½” washer, and pinion retainer nut. Then tighten by hand only.



    Now put a little sealant around the bearing housing…where it seats back into the drive housing. This will insure a good seal so no gear oil will leak from the interface. Yes yes there is an o-ring seal but I am always extra cautious. Besides the OEM housing appeared to have Yamabond on it upon disassembly.

    Next slide the re-assembled pinion assembly back into the drive housing. Make sure the pinion shims are in place…and not laying on the floor somewhere. This is critical since the entire drive was shimmed for gear lash at the factory.

    Also when re-inserting the bearing housing into the drive...pay attention to the lube hole in the bearing housing. They should line up with the cavitation channels on the inside of the drive housing. These channels allow oil to freely flow from the gear spinning into the lube holes and around the pinion bearings.

    Next take a couple of the shaft housing nuts and some extra washers and snug the pinion assembly into the drive housing. This will seat the O-ring seal and the sealant you just applied to the bearing housing.

    I did all these preliminary steps before I ever disassembled the OEM drive. At this point I let the XS750 drive sit overnight so the sealant would cure. I don’t think that is absolutely necessary, but I took the precaution.

    Next (the following evening) I began the arduous process of field stripping the Eleven’s OEM final drive. Remove the rear wheel. Then remove the left shock from the drive housing. Next break the four shaft housing nuts loose from the OEM drive and slide the drive gear coupling out of the shaft housing. After this you’ll see the Eleven’s shaft remains in it’s housing.



    Now you can measure the distance of the shaft face to the housing face. Then measure the distance of the XS750 drive housing face to end of the splines. This will tell you exactly how much spacing you need for a collar or length to extend your shaft. Depends on which route you take. In either case it turns out you’ll need about 5/8 to 11/16 inches ( 16 to 17 mm).

    Next remove the shaft from the housing. The service manual recommends a slide hammer. And that is what I did. With two bearing puller arms and a slide it popped right out. Pull the circlip off the shaft. It won't be used again.

    The two options for shaft modification will be discussed here: 1- spacer option ; 2- shaft extension.

    The shaft extension will comprise cutting a stock XS11 drive shaft and stretching it by 17mm, using a collar and pins to secure it. I took a spare shaft I had to a reputable machine shop. The machinist told me the only way he could extend the shaft would be to collar and pin it. He said (and I quote)”…that shaft is harder than the hubs of hell…” In order to weld it he would have to heat the shaft and allow it to cool very slowly to soften the thing where he could cut it and weld it. If he tried to TIG the hardened surface he assured me the weld would break. In order to weld it the estimate for the process was not going to be cost effective. So I told him to simply cut it an collar/pin it.

    The second option is actually the one I chose for several reasons. One is cost. Another simplicity. But the most important is strength. With a shaft that has been cut …then collared and pinned …the original material has been compromised. Even a welded shaft…if you chose to spend the money…would in my opinion be weaker than the spacer option. Because the original shaft would still have to be cut …collared and welded.

    There is no need to jump through all these hoops when a simple spacer (copper bushing) can be made to effectively accomplish the same task. Upon studying the Eleven’s splines that interface with the U-joint yoke I could see that about 24 mm of spline is being utilized. Notice the 3mm or so splines beyond the circlip groove are not used in the OEM configuration. These splines protrude past the u-joint yoke receiver and a circlip holds them in place. I have yet to ascertain why the circlip is there. There is no way for the shaft to ever come out of the yoke once in place. The circlip is appears to be some “over-engineered” design.



    Next I cut a ¾ inch copper sweat coupling (like you’d find at a hardware store)…I cut it 16mm long.



    Then I slipped it over the shaft. At the drive end of the U-joint spline I slipped a 5/8 x 3/4x 1/16 O-ring to act as a retainer for the copper spacer. It will hold the spacer in place as the shaft spins reducing wear to the copper. I also coated the shaft splines in that area the collar covers with RTV to help hold the copper in place and reduce vibration. I don’t know that this is nessecary but It can not hurt. Then at the yoke end of the collar I slipped another O-ring. In theory this will keep the copper from rubbing directly against the yoke housing and should reduce wear to the end of the collar. And again – if the O-ring fails overtime it’s no big loss. The o-ring can’t hurt anything…it can only help.





    After all this modification you can now see there is still 21.5 mm of spline length to engage the yoke. We’ve only lost less than 3mm of spline length. This should barely compromise the strength of the spline interface. Plus using this mod method we have not compromised the torsional strength of the shaft. And last but not least…this method cost a fraction of the other. Again…kudos to Chop for figuring all this crap out. I am merely the messenger relaying the procedure to all the brethren.

    Next I pulled the rubber boot of the shaft housing away where I could hold the U-joint yoke straight to re-insert the shaft. Make sure the shaft is full inserted. Now with the copper spacer the shaft will no longer be recessed into the shaft housing. It should be nearly flush with the end of the shaft housing…actually mine protruded about 1 – 2 mm.

    Next I removed the shaft retention spring from the Eleven’s pinion assembly and swapped it with the 750 spring. The 1100 spring is slightly longer and should do a better job of keeping the shaft fully engaged at the yoke end. Not necessary…just my method.

    Next grease the inside of the gear coupling splines really well. Now slide the 750 housing up into the 1100 shaft housing. You’ll have to turn the wheel splines to help line the gear coupling splines up to the shaft so they will lock. When you get it sync’d the drive housing will seat flush against the shaft housing. Install the four housing nuts and tighten.

    Don’t forget to fill the 750 drive with 90 wt gear oil. What shame to do all this work only to burn up the newly installed drive. Oh yes …and pump the shaft housing full of grease...you know at the shaft housing grease zirk. Dan Hodges tells me the spec calls for 30 cc of grease and that a standard grease gun is 1 cc per stroke. Do the math.



    Re-install the rear wheel (grease those splines slightly too)…button and bolt everything back up. Now RIDE!!! And watch you gas mileage FLY!!! You top end speed should be to shabby either.

    Cody
    29
    Antarctic in July cool - chilly chilly chilly
    51.72%
    15
    Colder than Hillary's mammary gland on a January morning at her Vail mansion.
    44.83%
    13
    About as cool as a day old cup of Starbucks -(Harley rider response)
    3.45%
    1

  • #2
    Real World

    I took Zilla down the road tonight for a test. Here's the result. I vividly recall prior to the mod spinning 4000 @ 60 mph and 5000 at 80 mph:

    Post Mod:

    50 mph - 2750 rpm
    60 mph - 3250 rpm
    70 mph - 3950 rpm
    80 mph - 4400 rpm
    90 mph - 4950 rpm

    The bike launches perfectly. Of course Zilla is making 95 hp and 70 ft-lbs. However when I rode Chop's stock Eleven it launched fine too.

    This mod - IMO - is absolutely one of the biggest bang for the buck mods you can do.

    XS750 Drive cost $70 delivered to my door from ebay.

    The copper collar cost $1.07.

    A can of sealant was $4.99

    2 - O-rings - 50 cents

    1 - 1/2 inch flat washer was a quarter.

    The smile on my face - PRICELESS!



    PS: I'll report back with gas mileage results later.

    Comment


    • #3
      Man, That figures......................Was watching 750 FD on e-bay yesterday and let it go Back to searching...........Thanks MAXIMAN for the detailed mod.
      "Elvira"
      '80 XS1100LG

      Comment


      • #4
        Max, the pinion gears, from what I've heard, if seperated, they'll need re-adjusting for backlash, if not, the teeth'll wear out before long!!

        Comment


        • #5
          Not true. I talked to Dan Hodges (a real guru) and he said it shouldn't be a problem as long as it goes back withe same shim.

          Also the head mechanic at the local dealer told me same thing.

          However if you are in doubt then grab a dial indicator and double check the gear lash.

          Comment


          • #6
            WOW !! Great Work MAXIMAN and XSCHOP!! CHOP for your Great idea's and Max for putting it in words a idiot like me can understand
            MY wife is always constantly laffing at me because Im always trying to make that shift into 6th gear and it not there .Time to look into theXS750 drive Great Post ! Great Pictures Great Job!
            I can see a price increase in 750 final drives now

            Cheers

            Comment


            • #7
              ONE MORE THING. This is important.

              Before re-inserting the modified XS750 drive housing into the shaft housing you should snug the pinion retainer nut a bit more than hand tight.

              If you pay particular attention to the unit before disassembly you'll notice the drive will spin readily by hand. It will not "free spin" but it is not hard to turn either.

              The only torque spec I could find for a 22mm nut in the service manual said - 94 ft-lbs!!! There is no way the drive gears will spin easily with that much torque. So I re-inserted the drive on the old XS wheel and used a 22mm deep socket. Then I adjusted the torque pretty tight by hand. This was to compress the two mating faces and the pinion shims to tolerance.

              Then I backed it off feeling the spinning resistance until I got it very close to what it was before.

              I put a torque wrench on it for grins and I think is was about 12 ft-lbs...not much for the big 22mm nut. In any case the nut is going nowhere since it is the lock variety.

              Cg
              Last edited by MAXIMAN; 10-27-2006, 08:43 AM.

              Comment


              • #8
                Very cool

                I'm not in any hurry to mod one of my Xs's but think it's very possible might do so next year. Will be looking forward to hearing if still no problems after several thousands of miles......

                On the RPM side of things, maybe my tack is off, but have noticed my 80G is turning 5,000 at 70 MPH and occasionally have tried to shift up with out thinking.

                XSELLENT presentation

                mro

                Comment


                • #9
                  MRO

                  What brand tire and size are you using?

                  One thing that can cause difference in rpm/speed is the variation in tire OD. I've seen 130/90 -16 range from just over 25 inches to almost 26 inches OD.

                  Also my OEM speedometer was off by 7 mph! I check it several ways (GPS, Stopwatch.etc). When indicating 5000 rpm I was indicating 73 or 74 mph. But the calculations ...GPS..and mile markers indicated I was closer to 80.

                  After I did the '79 SF speedo transplant (160 mph) on FrankenZilla ...my speed was thereafter "dead nut on". After that mod I was indicating 5000 at 80 and the GPS and gear reduction calculations for my Avon Venoms backed it up. So I'm pretty sure my speedo is on the money.

                  Now my RPM is 4400 at 80. The GPS and gear calculation re-inforce this fact.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    miles

                    I have been over 700 miles and only 3 TANKS SINCE! I don't plan on changing back to the guzzler mode no matter how quick she was off the line. 4th gear is now killer at 70 mph, Perfect for higher speed hiway traffic weaving and passing.....Chop
                    MDRNF
                    79F.....Not Stock
                    80G......Not Stock Either....In the works

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Continental 130/90 17

                      Have 2 other new tires in shop, both 130/90 17's.
                      Got me curious, will have to see if height is different.

                      Have added Continental to my list of tires not to buy. Front and rear are just about worn out with only 3,500 miles on em....
                      Could be.......you get what you pay for


                      mro

                      btw, how’s the XScceleration for 2nd and 3rd. On your hot scoot must be awesome..

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        50+ MPG???

                        That's significant, especially with fuel costs today.

                        Agree with Cody, best mod for 2006


                        mro

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          avg.

                          I am averaging 45 mpg....that's with the 16in rear Metzler. I don't know the O.D. though, I can measure when I get back to the house....
                          MDRNF
                          79F.....Not Stock
                          80G......Not Stock Either....In the works

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            "I am averaging 45 mpg...."


                            To me that would be bonus 45 mpg but just lowering the rpms of that motor is the greatest accomplishment and to me most rewarding
                            just my 2 cents worth .

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Great mod, no matter if you want it or not. If I rode long distances more often I would probably be all about it. But, I like riding right at the bottom of the power curve. When I twist, it rips!
                              '81 XS1100 SH

                              Melted to the ground during The Valley Fire

                              Sep. 12th 2015

                              RIP

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X