Chrome vs Nickel Plating

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • BillyRok
    XStremely XSive
    • Aug 2011
    • 420
    • Shortsville, NY.

    #1

    Chrome vs Nickel Plating

    I'm looking at re-plating some parts, specifically the frame for the hard bags and a luggage rack / back rest combo. I've sent photos to some plating shops in my area and am waiting for quotes. What experience do members have with either chrome or nickel plating? Any thoughts on the pros and cons of either method. There are just times where the plating on fenders, handle bars, etc is too far gone to polish back to a nice finish. Thanks for the input.
    Billy

    1982 XJ1100, Ceramic Coated Headers, Raptor ACCT, Barnett Clutch Springs, Dremmel Fix, TC's Fuse Block, De-Linked S/S Brake Lines, 850 Final Drive, Yahman's YICS Eliminator, Pods, stock jets
  • jetmechmarty
    Master of XSology
    • Nov 2003
    • 7761
    • Coldwater, Mississippi

    #2
    Nickel should be plated under the chrome. Does that help?
    Marty (in Mississippi)
    XS1100SG
    XS650SK
    XS650SH
    XS650G
    XS6502F
    XS650E

    Comment

    • DiverRay
      Moderator
      • Nov 2004
      • 7589
      • Star, IDAHO

      #3
      Chrome is what gives the nickel plating the ability to shine for years. It keeps the silver from oxidizing and turning black. It is also a very hard plating, and will keep things from wearing through the nickel.
      Ray Matteis
      KE6NHG
      XS1100 E '78 (winter project)
      XS1100 SF Bob Jones worked on it!

      Comment

      • Jerry
        XS & TRUE XJ GURU
        • Jun 2002
        • 3023
        • Elma, IA.

        #4
        If you nickel plate without the chrome you get a different finish, more muted and less shine. Before chrome plating was practical, older vehicles used nickel because that was what was available. One advantage of nickel is that it bends a bit more without cracking. Does take more work to keep it from oxidizing.
        Jerry Fields
        '82 XJ 'Sojourn'
        '06 Concours
        My Galleries Page.
        My Blog Page.
        "... life is just a honky-tonk show." Cherry Poppin' Daddy Strut

        Comment

        • BillyRok
          XStremely XSive
          • Aug 2011
          • 420
          • Shortsville, NY.

          #5
          OK, thanks for the replies. Looks like chrome is the better way to go. Got a couple quotes, pretty pricey and not many places that do it. If I spend this money I'll never be able to complain to my wife again about beauty products!
          Billy

          1982 XJ1100, Ceramic Coated Headers, Raptor ACCT, Barnett Clutch Springs, Dremmel Fix, TC's Fuse Block, De-Linked S/S Brake Lines, 850 Final Drive, Yahman's YICS Eliminator, Pods, stock jets

          Comment

          • jetmechmarty
            Master of XSology
            • Nov 2003
            • 7761
            • Coldwater, Mississippi

            #6
            Originally posted by BillyRok
            If I spend this money I'll never be able to complain to my wife again about beauty products!
            You got that right!
            Marty (in Mississippi)
            XS1100SG
            XS650SK
            XS650SH
            XS650G
            XS6502F
            XS650E

            Comment

            • MPittma100
              XS-XJ Guru
              • Aug 2011
              • 2359
              • Atlanta, GA.

              #7
              $$$

              Originally posted by BillyRok
              OK, thanks for the replies. Looks like chrome is the better way to go. Got a couple quotes, pretty pricey and not many places that do it. If I spend this money I'll never be able to complain to my wife again about beauty products!
              SPEND it! Make it shine.
              1981 XS1100H Venturer
              K&N Air Filter
              ACCT
              Custom Paint by Deitz
              Geezer Rectifier/Regulator
              Chacal Stainless Steel Braided Brake Lines
              Chrome Front Rotor & Caliper Covers
              Stebel Nautilus Horn
              EBC Front Rotors
              Limie Accent Moves On In 2015

              Mike

              Comment

              • fredintoon
                Master of XSology
                • Mar 2004
                • 6795
                • Saskatoon SK

                #8
                Originally posted by BillyRok
                I'm looking at re-plating some parts, specifically the frame for the hard bags and a luggage rack / back rest combo. I've sent photos to some plating shops in my area and am waiting for quotes. What experience do members have with either chrome or nickel plating? Any thoughts on the pros and cons of either method. There are just times where the plating on fenders, handle bars, etc is too far gone to polish back to a nice finish. Thanks for the input.
                Hi Billy,
                "chrome" plating is a 3 layer process.
                first layer is copper because it sticks good.
                Next layer is the nickel which does the actual protection.
                Last layer is the chrome to look pretty.
                Back in the 1930s & earlier they mostly stopped at the nickel layer and polished it instead of adding the chrome.
                The "look" you want is up to you.
                Fred Hill, S'toon
                XS11SG with Spirit of America sidecar
                "The Flying Pumpkin"

                Comment

                • motoman
                  Master of XSology
                  • Aug 2005
                  • 8413
                  • Grand Junction, Colorado

                  #9
                  Good to see you posting again Fred!......just remember, you can 'check out' but never leave.
                  81H Venturer1100 "The Bentley" (on steroids) 97 Yamaha YZ250(age reducer) 92 Honda ST1100 "Twisty"(touring rocket) Age is relative to the number of seconds counted 'airing' out an 85ft. table-top.

                  Comment

                  Working...