If the process is anything like on wheels, it's not the material that's used which is the issue; it's the method of production. The structure of cast alloy is much more granular with 'open' spaces between the grains (or whatever the correct term is) Hence cast alloy wheels being quite hefty, compared to forged. Forging..effectively whacking a component out of a block, results in a tighter metallic structure which means that the component can be 'finer' without loss of strength. I have forged alloy wheels on my XJR and the spokes are much thinner than cast, the hubs much smaller and the point where the spokes join the rim is very thin indeed. Cast alloy, because of its nature, would without doubt crack.
So, personally, if at all possible and cost-effective, I'd go for forged pistons as opposed to cast. Same goes for conrods.... Forged replacements are available and they are much finer in appearance, possibly easier to balance on the crank etc. I don't imagine there's much of a performance increase to warrant the expense though!
As people have said, for a bike like the XS1100, forged engine components are probably overkill..... Still nice though!
So, personally, if at all possible and cost-effective, I'd go for forged pistons as opposed to cast. Same goes for conrods.... Forged replacements are available and they are much finer in appearance, possibly easier to balance on the crank etc. I don't imagine there's much of a performance increase to warrant the expense though!
As people have said, for a bike like the XS1100, forged engine components are probably overkill..... Still nice though!
Comment