Question about testing coils

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • vcgodinich
    XSive
    • Aug 2009
    • 20

    #1

    Question about testing coils

    Rebuilding a bike, decided to replace the coils with the ones from mikexs... the green ones.

    Tested them, they spark fine. About a week later, cylinders 1&4 have no spark. Switched orange / grey wires, still no spark on 1&4, but 2&3 still have spark, so electrical up to the coils is fine.

    Took off the questionable coil and ohmed across the primary coil, ~4 OHMs. Across the secondary ~14k. Primary to secondary is open.

    So that all seems like the coil is good...

    Put it back on, turned on the key and there is 12v between ground and orange/grey and also 12v between redwhite stripe and ground. So that seems normal, right?

    All I have switched spark plugs and spark plug wires, so that is not the problem.

    So is my new coil just toast, or is there something I am just overlooking?
  • DAVINCI
    XS-XJ Guru
    • Jan 2011
    • 1048
    • Cedar Mountain, NC

    #2
    Re-solder the TCI pins.

    Look here:

    Former owner, but I have NO PARTS LEFT!

    Comment

    • fredintoon
      Master of XSology
      • Mar 2004
      • 6795
      • Saskatoon SK

      #3
      Originally posted by vcgodinich
      Rebuilding a bike, decided to replace the coils with the ones from mikexs... the green ones.
      Tested them, they spark fine. About a week later, cylinders 1&4 have no spark. Switched orange / grey wires, still no spark on 1&4, but 2&3 still have spark, so electrical up to the coils is fine.
      Took off the questionable coil and ohmed across the primary coil, ~4 OHMs. Across the secondary ~14k. Primary to secondary is open.
      So that all seems like the coil is good...
      Put it back on, turned on the key and there is 12v between ground and orange/grey and also 12v between redwhite stripe and ground. So that seems normal, right?
      All I have switched spark plugs and spark plug wires, so that is not the problem.
      So is my new coil just toast, or is there something I am just overlooking?
      Hi VC,
      Just maybe you missed a step?
      You say Switched orange / grey wires, still no spark on 1&4, but 2&3 still have spark,
      But you DIDN'T say you swapped the plug wires to match.
      Swapping the orange and grey wires without swapping the plug wires to match puts the coils 180º out of phase but don't change which plugs the coils fire.
      Fred Hill, S'toon
      XS11SG with Spirit of America sidecar
      "The Flying Pumpkin"

      Comment

      • natemoen
        Master of XSology
        • May 2010
        • 8640
        • Fargo

        #4
        Originally posted by DAVINCI
        Good to see you back here again Randy!
        Nathan
        KD9ARL

        μολὼν λαβέ

        1978 XS1100E
        K&N Filter
        #45 pilot Jet, #137.5 Main Jet
        OEM Exhaust
        ATK Fork Brace
        LED Dash lights
        Ammeter, Oil Pressure, Oil Temp, and Volt Meters

        Green Monster Coils
        SS Brake Lines
        Vision 550 Auto Tensioner

        In any moment of decision the best thing you can do is the right thing, the next best thing is the wrong thing, and the worst thing you can do is nothing.

        Theodore Roosevelt

        Comment

        • vcgodinich
          XSive
          • Aug 2009
          • 20

          #5
          Originally posted by fredintoon
          Hi VC,
          Just maybe you missed a step?
          You say Switched orange / grey wires, still no spark on 1&4, but 2&3 still have spark,
          But you DIDN'T say you swapped the plug wires to match.
          Swapping the orange and grey wires without swapping the plug wires to match puts the coils 180º out of phase but don't change which plugs the coils fire.
          I was pulling the plugs out, grounding them and looking for a spark, not trying to actually start it. It should have sparked, unless I am just missing something here...

          Comment

          • GLoweVA
            XS-XJ Guru
            • Jun 2011
            • 1957
            • Virginia Beach, VA.

            #6
            Make sure that both plugs of the pair are touching the engine.
            These bikes use a wasted spark system and both plugs spark at the same time and in order to complete the circuit, both plugs need to be grounded.
            Also check to make sure the gaps are good too.
            Are you checking your secondaries from the plug cap to plug cap?
            Hi, my name is George & I'm a twisty addict!

            80G (Green paint(PO idea))
            The Green Monster
            K&N A/F, TC's fuse block, '81 oil cooler, TC's homemade 4-2 w/Mac Mufflers, Raptor 660 ACCT
            Got him in '04.
            bald tire & borrowing parts

            80SG (Black w/red emblems & calipers)
            Scarlet
            K&N A/F, TC's fuse block, WJ5, Shoei bags, Raptor 660 ACCT.
            Got her in '11
            Ready for the twisties!

            81H (previously CPMaynard's)
            Hugo
            Full Venturer, Indigo Blue with B/W painted tank.
            Cold weather ride

            Comment

            • vcgodinich
              XSive
              • Aug 2009
              • 20

              #7
              Originally posted by GLoweVA
              Make sure that both plugs of the pair are touching the engine.
              These bikes use a wasted spark system and both plugs spark at the same time and in order to complete the circuit, both plugs need to be grounded.
              Also check to make sure the gaps are good too.
              Are you checking your secondaries from the plug cap to plug cap?
              Yes, I had the other 3 plugged in at the time, and would only test one out, grounded.

              The gaps are good, I switched spark plugs to one from the other cylinder that I know sparks fine.

              Will check cap to cap... I was just testing at the coil. Good idea.

              Checked cap to cap, same ~14k.
              Last edited by vcgodinich; 07-12-2013, 02:20 PM.

              Comment

              • GLoweVA
                XS-XJ Guru
                • Jun 2011
                • 1957
                • Virginia Beach, VA.

                #8
                If you've got stanndard resistor caps, those can get a little corroded inside.
                If you look down into the hole you'll see a slot for a flat head screwdriver, you can then unscrew it and the resistor and spring should fall out.
                Clean it up with some rubbing alcohol or carb cleaner and a q-tip. (or de-oxit if you've got some)

                Another faulty place is the wire end where the cap screws into the wire.
                The wire can get a little corroded too, the fix there is to trim off about a 1/4" of the wire and screw the cap back on.

                Okay, not the best pic in the world, but at least it shows you that the plugs do indeed come off the wires:
                Hi, my name is George & I'm a twisty addict!

                80G (Green paint(PO idea))
                The Green Monster
                K&N A/F, TC's fuse block, '81 oil cooler, TC's homemade 4-2 w/Mac Mufflers, Raptor 660 ACCT
                Got him in '04.
                bald tire & borrowing parts

                80SG (Black w/red emblems & calipers)
                Scarlet
                K&N A/F, TC's fuse block, WJ5, Shoei bags, Raptor 660 ACCT.
                Got her in '11
                Ready for the twisties!

                81H (previously CPMaynard's)
                Hugo
                Full Venturer, Indigo Blue with B/W painted tank.
                Cold weather ride

                Comment

                • vcgodinich
                  XSive
                  • Aug 2009
                  • 20

                  #9
                  Originally posted by DAVINCI
                  Question before I go melting things... if the TCI was bad, wouldn't swapping the orange / grey cables make the "bad" coil work? Because it didn't in my case. And the other coil worked with the swap, so wouldn't that mean that the TCI is working fine?

                  Comment

                  • GLoweVA
                    XS-XJ Guru
                    • Jun 2011
                    • 1957
                    • Virginia Beach, VA.

                    #10
                    Originally posted by vcgodinich
                    Yes, I had the other 3 plugged in at the time, and would only test one out, grounded.

                    The gaps are good, I switched spark plugs to one from the other cylinder that I know sparks fine.

                    Will check cap to cap... I was just testing at the coil. Good idea.

                    Checked cap to cap, same ~14k.
                    Just saw that last line:
                    So 14K cap to cap, that's good, so either the TCI isn't telling the coil to fire, or the pick up coil aren't telling the TCI to fire.
                    Hi, my name is George & I'm a twisty addict!

                    80G (Green paint(PO idea))
                    The Green Monster
                    K&N A/F, TC's fuse block, '81 oil cooler, TC's homemade 4-2 w/Mac Mufflers, Raptor 660 ACCT
                    Got him in '04.
                    bald tire & borrowing parts

                    80SG (Black w/red emblems & calipers)
                    Scarlet
                    K&N A/F, TC's fuse block, WJ5, Shoei bags, Raptor 660 ACCT.
                    Got her in '11
                    Ready for the twisties!

                    81H (previously CPMaynard's)
                    Hugo
                    Full Venturer, Indigo Blue with B/W painted tank.
                    Cold weather ride

                    Comment

                    • vcgodinich
                      XSive
                      • Aug 2009
                      • 20

                      #11
                      Originally posted by GLoweVA
                      If you've got stanndard resistor caps, those can get a little corroded inside.
                      If you look down into the hole you'll see a slot for a flat head screwdriver, you can then unscrew it and the resistor and spring should fall out.
                      Clean it up with some rubbing alcohol or carb cleaner and a q-tip. (or de-oxit if you've got some)

                      Another faulty place is the wire end where the cap screws into the wire.
                      The wire can get a little corroded too, the fix there is to trim off about a 1/4" of the wire and screw the cap back on.

                      Okay, not the best pic in the world, but at least it shows you that the plugs do indeed come off the wires:
                      I am using the XS coils... and the caps that came with them. As I understand it, they aren't resistor caps. All of the connections are new, and worked for a time, and I have looked them all over. I did an OHM reading of the secondary through the cables, so wouldn't that rule out any problems with them?

                      Comment

                      • GLoweVA
                        XS-XJ Guru
                        • Jun 2011
                        • 1957
                        • Virginia Beach, VA.

                        #12
                        Originally posted by vcgodinich
                        Question before I go melting things... if the TCI was bad, wouldn't swapping the orange / grey cables make the "bad" coil work? Because it didn't in my case. And the other coil worked with the swap, so wouldn't that mean that the TCI is working fine?
                        Make sure that the red/white wire has a good connection from the coil back to the TCI.
                        Hi, my name is George & I'm a twisty addict!

                        80G (Green paint(PO idea))
                        The Green Monster
                        K&N A/F, TC's fuse block, '81 oil cooler, TC's homemade 4-2 w/Mac Mufflers, Raptor 660 ACCT
                        Got him in '04.
                        bald tire & borrowing parts

                        80SG (Black w/red emblems & calipers)
                        Scarlet
                        K&N A/F, TC's fuse block, WJ5, Shoei bags, Raptor 660 ACCT.
                        Got her in '11
                        Ready for the twisties!

                        81H (previously CPMaynard's)
                        Hugo
                        Full Venturer, Indigo Blue with B/W painted tank.
                        Cold weather ride

                        Comment

                        • GLoweVA
                          XS-XJ Guru
                          • Jun 2011
                          • 1957
                          • Virginia Beach, VA.

                          #13
                          If the secondaries are ohming out good and the primaries too, then the coil isn't getting the right voltage from the TCI. You swapped the orange and grey, but the coil needs a 'return' path ie the rew/white. Check that connection.
                          Hi, my name is George & I'm a twisty addict!

                          80G (Green paint(PO idea))
                          The Green Monster
                          K&N A/F, TC's fuse block, '81 oil cooler, TC's homemade 4-2 w/Mac Mufflers, Raptor 660 ACCT
                          Got him in '04.
                          bald tire & borrowing parts

                          80SG (Black w/red emblems & calipers)
                          Scarlet
                          K&N A/F, TC's fuse block, WJ5, Shoei bags, Raptor 660 ACCT.
                          Got her in '11
                          Ready for the twisties!

                          81H (previously CPMaynard's)
                          Hugo
                          Full Venturer, Indigo Blue with B/W painted tank.
                          Cold weather ride

                          Comment

                          • vcgodinich
                            XSive
                            • Aug 2009
                            • 20

                            #14
                            Originally posted by GLoweVA
                            Just saw that last line:
                            So 14K cap to cap, that's good, so either the TCI isn't telling the coil to fire, or the pick up coil aren't telling the TCI to fire.
                            Yeah, but using the other wires (orange / grey) that I know are working, it still doesn't fire.

                            Comment

                            • vcgodinich
                              XSive
                              • Aug 2009
                              • 20

                              #15
                              Originally posted by GLoweVA
                              If the secondaries are ohming out good and the primaries too, then the coil isn't getting the right voltage from the TCI. You swapped the orange and grey, but the coil needs a 'return' path ie the rew/white. Check that connection.
                              I looked it over and it seemed okay. I checked the fork place.

                              If it were the return, I shouldn't be able to measure ~12v at the orange / grey when the key is on, right? Or are you saying to do a loop test from the front red/white to the back red/white at the TCI? If that were bad, wouldn't both coils not work?
                              Last edited by vcgodinich; 07-12-2013, 02:32 PM.

                              Comment

                              Working...