Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

fun with rings.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • fun with rings.

    I am trying to rebuild the top end of the G, and I have a question for the ring experts.

    I have checked the end gap of some new rings, std size, and they are just slightly out of spec.

    The max for an 80 is .016, and i am getting .018. The rings that came out were .084.

    I have 2 sets of 1st over rings, and if I put them in, they overlap, of course as they are slightly too big.

    Do you think I would be able to use 1st over rings on std pistons if I file for the end gap, or would I be better off using stock rings slightly out of spec?

    I have 2 sets of 1st over and 1 set std, so i need one more set either way.
    Nice day, if it doesn't rain...

    '05 ST1300
    '83 502/502 Monte Carlo for sale/trade

  • #2
    I wouldn't worry about .002" on an end gap, personally.
    I think using 1st over on a std bore is acceptable also, but it takes a little more breakin time.
    Last edited by oseaghdha; 04-29-2009, 05:01 AM.
    XS1100SF
    XS1100F

    Comment


    • #3
      Since you'll have an initial break in when you put it back together, this will make your slightly out of spec stock ones even further out. They will work if it's just all you have, but you'll get better compression using the other ones and filing them down. I would only do that to the first two compression rings though. I'd just clean up and re-use the oil ring. This one would be really tricky to get right, and there's actually three rings in that one between the top, bottom and wavy rings. A stock one cleaned up should still wipe the cylinders fine and has nothing to do with your compression numbers. Get this one just a little wrong and you score the cylinder and/or burn lots of oil.


      Tod
      Try your hardest to be the kind of person your dog thinks you are.

      You can live to be 100, as long as you give up everything that would make you want to live to be 100!

      Current bikes:
      '06 Suzuki DR650
      *'82 XJ1100 with the 1179 kit. "Mad Maxim"
      '82 XJ1100 Completely stock fixer-upper
      '82 XJ1100 Bagger fixer-upper
      '82 XJ1100 Motor/frame and lots of boxes of parts
      '82 XJ1100 Parts bike
      '81 XS1100 Special
      '81 YZ250
      '80 XS850 Special
      '80 XR100
      *Crashed/Totalled, still own

      Comment


      • #4
        Well, using 1st (or 2nd, 3rd) overrings on std pistons goes against my mechanic training, such as it is, but I have heard of other people doing it.

        As I mentioned, I have 2 sets of 1st over and 1 set of std. I just need to find 2 more sets of 1st over, or 3 sets of std. To me the extra .002 is no biggie, either. The specs in the manual are the max the factory will let out. The max service limit is really where the bike becomes an oil burner or has no compression.

        I am not sure if the oil rings on the bike are correct. I can't see .084 clearance on stock rings, unless the motor had 150,000miles on it. None of the rest of the block shows this much wear. In fact, the cylinders on this one are better than the ones off the bike originally, and it only had 38,000kms on it.

        It looks like the PO re-ringed the motor, with either the wrong rings, or they wore out really fast. He had not staggered the gaps, either.

        Remember this is the bike that had the awful oil consumption and no top end power.
        Last edited by Crazcnuk; 04-29-2009, 12:23 PM.
        Nice day, if it doesn't rain...

        '05 ST1300
        '83 502/502 Monte Carlo for sale/trade

        Comment


        • #5
          I don't know nearly enough to cmoonet ont he gap and such, but even I know if you do not offset the ring gaps, you will lose compression and burn plenty oil!
          Life is what happens while your planning everything else!

          When your work speaks for itself, don't interrupt.

          81 XS1100 Special - Humpty Dumpty
          80 XS1100 Special - Project Resurrection


          Previously owned
          93 GSX600F
          80 XS1100 Special - Ruby
          81 XS1100 Special
          81 CB750 C
          80 CB750 C
          78 XS750

          Comment


          • #6
            That was the problem. This motor burnt a lot of oil. With the rings over twice the maximum service limit and the gaps together on all 4 cylinders, the oil rings were trying to be the 3rd compression ring!

            I just bought 4 sets of 1st over rings off of ebay for under $50. I will use these and make them fit, unless someone wants to trade 1st overs for standards.

            Also I found my Supplemental Service manual and it shows the max service limit as .0394". The manual just says .016.
            Last edited by Crazcnuk; 04-29-2009, 05:03 PM.
            Nice day, if it doesn't rain...

            '05 ST1300
            '83 502/502 Monte Carlo for sale/trade

            Comment


            • #7
              I think the oil rings are pretty important especially if that motor was a smoker.
              You may be able to use your old wavy ring and use new for the other two oil rings just file em on the ends to fit.
              80 SG XS1100
              14 Victory Cross Country

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by Crazcnuk View Post
                That was the problem. This motor burnt a lot of oil. With the rings over twice the maximum service limit and the gaps together on all 4 cylinders, the oil rings were trying to be the 3rd compression ring!

                I just bought 4 sets of 1st over rings off of ebay for under $50. I will use these and make them fit, unless someone wants to trade 1st overs for standards.

                Also I found my Supplemental Service manual and it shows the max service limit as .0394". The manual just says .016.
                Holy Moly! I've been waiting to find out what was wrong with that engine! 0.084" end gap on the oil rails and the gaps all lined up? Using oil rails as compression rings wiped out those poor little oil rails. How much of them is left? They must look like slivers.

                I'm in the middle of fitting new Standard rings to my '80G and the new, Standard, rings are smaller than the original rings. Go figure. Your 0.018" end gap is probably okay for new, Standard rings if, like the ones I bought, they're a hair or two smaller than the originals.

                The new rings in mine gap at about 0.013"~0.016" for the compresssion rings and 0.020"~0.022" for the oil rails. A couple of thousandths doesn't matter but if you want to get technical, measure the bore diameter to find the circumference, then work out the equivalent end gaps for new, smaller rings versus the old, original, rings and bore..

                Here are the measurements of my old rings and the new rings. The old rings have 39,000 miles on them. The new rings are Yamaha 3J2-11610-00-00 (STD).

                Measured Standard Size Ring Width and Thickness:

                Top Ring (RN):
                Old: 3.033mm/0.1194" Wide
                New:3.007mm/0.1184" Wide

                Old: 1.168mm/0.046" Thick
                New: 1.180mm/0.0464" Thick


                2nd Ring (R):
                Old:3.096mm/0.1219" Wide
                New: 2.974mm/0.1171" Wide

                Old:1.516mm/0.597" Thick
                New: 1.483mm/0.0584" Thick


                Oil rails:
                Used: 2.289mm/0.0901" Wide
                New: 2.235mm/0.088" Wide

                Old: 0.460mm/0.0181" Thick
                New: 0.450mm/0.0177" Thick


                Regards,

                Scott
                -- Scott
                _____

                2004 ST1300A: No name... yet
                1982 XJ1100J: "Baby" SS Brakes, '850 FD, ACCT
                1980 XS1100G: "Columbo" SS Brakes, '850 FD, ACCT
                1979 XS1100SF: "Bush" W.I.P.
                1979 XS1100F: parts
                2018 Heritage Softail Classic 117 FLHCS SE: "Nanuk" It's DEAD, it's not just resting. It is an EX cycle.

                Comment


                • #9
                  I didn't check the gap on the oil rails. Just the compression rings.

                  There are very definite wear marks in the rails from the wavy seperator, though, more than I've seen before.

                  The compression was low, but not a lot. With nearly 1/8" of wide open space leading right to the top oil rail the oil ring was doing much more than it is supposed to.
                  Nice day, if it doesn't rain...

                  '05 ST1300
                  '83 502/502 Monte Carlo for sale/trade

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    rings

                    Hi, I would agree with your mechanics instinct about putting in the first oversize rings. I would worry that the larger rings would no longer be completely round after being squeezed that much into a smaller bore. The extra .002 on the stock size, I wouldn't worry about that at all. It's about how much Wiseco recommends for an increased gap for hot street motors.
                    Leo
                    1980 XS1100 Special
                    1197cc Wiseco kit
                    1978 cams
                    4 into 1 Jardine with glasspack
                    Keihin CR33 mm carbs
                    K&N individual pod filters
                    TKAT fork brace

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      What I have been told, by an expert, is that the larger rings will be slightly out of round as they are for a different radius of bore. However, he said that this just means it will take a little longer to break in, then they will be fine.

                      So he said to file the rings to the minimum ring gap .08 and by the time they settle in the gap will be about the middle of the recomended assy range around .012.

                      His take on the .018 gap for using the std ones is that they will still need a break in period and the gap will be .020 or better at that time, which is already halfway to the max service limit.
                      Nice day, if it doesn't rain...

                      '05 ST1300
                      '83 502/502 Monte Carlo for sale/trade

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X